The Blacksmith Posted August 27, 2024 Report Posted August 27, 2024 I would like to see pictures of the whole sword please. I could be wrong of course, and hopefully am, but to my eyes this seems more like a Chinese copy than a genuine Japanese blade.The shape and finish of the nakago, the very badly written and lightly inscribed kanji, the megugi ana etc. Several things do not seem right to me. 1 Quote
Bruce Pennington Posted August 27, 2024 Report Posted August 27, 2024 You might also find some small "W" stamps at the end or top, sometimes both, of the nakago. Quote
aabderson Posted August 27, 2024 Author Report Posted August 27, 2024 Do these pics help? Do you think it’s authentic? @Bruce Pennington @The Blacksmith Quote
aabderson Posted August 27, 2024 Author Report Posted August 27, 2024 @Bruce Pennington he sent me more pics of the nakago. It does have a W stamp. But not sure if that is what it should look like Quote
Bruce Pennington Posted August 28, 2024 Report Posted August 28, 2024 Yes! Excellent! They do not fake the W stamp. The blade is legitimate, I see nothing wrong with the fittings as legitimate World War II fittings. There is a mystery with the fuchi and tsuba. Both are World War III items, but they seem mismatched. Whether that was done during the war or after no one can know. Quote
Kyle68 Posted August 28, 2024 Report Posted August 28, 2024 @Bruce Pennington so from my reading about the W stamp, it appears primarily on Takehisa, Yoshiharu and the Mantetsu blades. Is that correct? Quote
Bruce Pennington Posted August 29, 2024 Report Posted August 29, 2024 On 8/28/2024 at 2:17 PM, Kyle68 said: it appears primarily on Takehisa, Yoshiharu and the Mantetsu blades. Is that correct? Expand Yes, primarily. I have single examples of the stamp on Haruhisa, Tenshin, and Kanenori blades, but 13-14 examples on Takehisa and Yoshiharu blades and 26 examples on Mantetsu. I do have a few examples on Type 19s and Type 95s as well. The dated blades from the smiths are all 1943 - 1945. The Matetsu range from 1942 - 1944. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.