William Jennings Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 Hello all, I'm still fairly new to collecting and I was wondering if I could get your opinions on this sword, specifically if it is real or fake. I guessed it was real but there is no mekugi to pull to view the nakago. what do you all think? Thanks in advance.... Quote
Ray Singer Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 Looks authentic. See examples below of white line. 1 Quote
Lee Bray Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 The kissaki suggests it is a real Nihonto but I think you'll get no more info on school or period from these photos. The handle is knot Japanese(lol , sorry). 2 Quote
William Jennings Posted July 3, 2024 Author Report Posted July 3, 2024 Okay! Thank you all! Any estimate on a possible value? Quote
Rivkin Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 Far away from my specialty, but I would think this is Vietnamese or from roughly the same region. Authentic. Possibly with Japanese blade, in which it will still have a drastically reworked and shortened nakago to accomodate a difference in style. 1 Quote
Jacques Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 I don't like the kissaki, its geometry is not correct but I could be wrong Quote
Shugyosha Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 1 hour ago, Jacques D. said: but I could be wrong 1 Quote
aabderson Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 Is the Tsuba real? It seems pretty crude and simple to me. Quote
lonely panet Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 6 hours ago, aabderson said: Is the Tsuba real? It seems pretty crude and simple to me. Its in the shape of early tsuba Quote
aabderson Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 Here are more pics. It seems to be round, not oval. @lonely panet Quote
Rivkin Posted July 3, 2024 Report Posted July 3, 2024 Japanese-like swords of the Continent are much lesser known than Japanese per se and I am definitely not very knowledgeable on those, but: Round/sometimes slightly elongated, tosho-like very large tsubas are usually Korean. It looks a bit recent (WWII?). Korean hilts tend to be longer which is why I was more inclined towards Vietnam at first. The knot wrapping is as was indicated above is later adoption and the whole assembly could be XXth century, though I think using an authentic blade and done not with the purpose to create a souvenir. Unfortunately the market for such blades is poor. I personally is interested but maybe its because my understanding of the subject is lacking. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.