SAMURAI SWORDS BANNED IN THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND

[Bazza]

A short time ago I reported the Irish police as having seized 7,000 swords. I have just found this discussion:

http://nihontoclub.com/news/samurai-swo ... in-ireland

 

The text accompanying the link (part of a discussion group) is below my sign off.

 

Regards,

Barry Thomas.

-------------------------------

Talks about potential sword ban started in December 2007 after another high profile attack involving a 'samurai sword'. It is known that Department of Justice had been in contact with local martial arts organisations (Iaido Association of Ireland is particular) is order to avoid unnecessary restrictions for martial arts practitioners and authentic sword collectors. In the light of recent global trends to regulate possession and transportation of 'samurai' swords (which sometimes comes in quite narrow-minded forms) the new Irish legislation appears to be reasonable, especially taking into account the (more than modest) size of the local sword scene. Mirroring the UK sword ban which was introduced in April 2008 as one of the questionable measures to fight 'knife crime', authentic hand-made Japanese swords (Nihonto) are exempt (however I couldn't yet find any reference to whether sports equipment such as iaito and shinken is to be banned or not).

 

The real concern is the practical side of the legislation and the way it's going to be implemented. There's been numerous occasions in UK since introduction of the sword ban when law-abiding collectors had trouble importing antique swords. It's perfectly understandable due to the fact that in order for Customs to make sure that it's legal to import a sword, some sort of certificate required proving its age and provenance. And the most common cert of this kind (if any) is the NBTHK paper hand-written in Japanese. No wonder Customs officers, sorting office workers and law enforcement authorities would not be able to take it as a supportive documentation without difficult (and costly) translation.And this is the neigbouring UK which is much more accustomed to importing/exporting Japanese collectible weapons than Irish. How many Customs officers and An Post employees were instructed about differences between replica and authentic Japanese swords or even have seen ones? Will they be collector-friendly or take an eBay approach and stop any import of 'illegal samurai-like swords' unless (with immense trouble) proven otherwise? If temporarily or permanently seized, will real Nihonto be given a proper care?

 

There is no doubt that circulation of cheap and dangerous replica had to be stopped, even with the level or crime involving samurai swords being ridiculously low in comparison to the usage of widely available home utensils.But will the fair treatment of martial arts practitioners and sword collectors be guaranteed? Time will tell.

[IanB]

Barry, It had to happen. It is sad to see that the Irish officials have fallen for the same 'made by traditional methods' phrase as the UK. Why on earth they thought it necessary to include this is beyond me. It really allows those importing mixed-metal junk from China to carry on importing since many Chinese swords were made in that way traditionally. How you would prove it was 'hand-done' is another matter. I've no doubt that once the Irish officials have had a few months practice, things will settle down as they have here.

Ian Bottomley