New Collector - Need your opinion on this piece.

[Bailey78]

24 minutes ago, Grey Doffin said:

Hi Andrew,

Don't know what you consider reasonable for a drive but there is the show in Las Vegas next January. There you can get opinions on your sword.

Grey

 

 So i should plan on telling my wife now i must go to Vegas in January. I feel this is justified except i haven't broken to her yet that i've bought 3 in the last month because this is rather addicting. 

[Jacques D.]

8 hours ago, Rivkin said:

 

 

As most shinto nie Sendai nie tends to be of the same size, Hosho varies within the blade.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Show me where you see nie and chikei on the sword object tof that topic

 

 

Quote

Hosho work tends to be more non-uniform, the width of masame varies, Sendai is very uniform.

Prove it please.

 

Quote

Some Hosho lineages practice a mixture of masame with Awataguchi level very fine itame, there are some Sendai smiths who could do that as well.

 

Show me a papered example please

 

 

Andrew @

 I would add Hosho tachi are extremely rare. Oh, is the mune nakago kaku (flat) ?

[Jacques D.]

8 hours ago, Rivkin said:

Hosho work tends to be more non-uniform, the width of masame varies, Sendai is very uniform.

 

 

 

Huh...

 

https://www.toukenko...&katana_A030522.html

[Bailey78]

6 hours ago, Jacques D. said:

 

Show me where you see nie and chikei on the sword object tof that topic

 

 

Prove it please.

 

 

Show me a papered example please

 

 

Andrew @

 I would add Hosho tachi are extremely rare. Oh, is the mune nakago kaku (flat) ?

Jacques,

Yes it is completely flat. 

[Bailey78]

7 hours ago, Jacques D. said:

 

Huh...

 

https://www.toukenko...&katana_A030522.html

Thanks. The nakago on the one i have is completely different than this one from what i can see. Not sure if that matters that much.

[Bailey78]

The file marks on the Nakago look to be straight across as well on my piece. Not sure if that says anything different either. 

[Jacques D.]

1 hour ago, Bailey78 said:

The file marks on the Nakago look to be straight across as well on my piece. Not sure if that says anything different either. 

 

The sword I've linked to is a Shinto sword (Sendai Kunikane), not a Hosho sword, so the yasurime don't have to be higaki. 

 

The nakago mune of a Hosho sword must be round.

[Guest Simon R]

It's gimei.

[Bailey78]

On 8/25/2023 at 10:11 AM, Jacques D. said:

 

The sword I've linked to is a Shinto sword (Sendai Kunikane), not a Hosho sword, so the yasurime don't have to be higaki. 

 

The nakago mune of a Hosho sword must be round.

 

I believe this is true(Sendai Kunikane). As i research more this seems to be the case.