Ooitame Posted May 11, 2023 Report Posted May 11, 2023 Well after a long time due, blood, sweat, and years, my Daisho is complete. Better pics to come along if you want, Shirasaya, Koshirae, no Habaki, hamon hada, Bohi, Sohi... Never let anyone tell you hardwork does not pay off. Patience as well lol! 5 1 Quote
PNSSHOGUN Posted May 12, 2023 Report Posted May 12, 2023 Hi Eric, congratulations. Do you have pictures of the Koshirae, the Katana and Wakizashi look to be from different time periods is all. 2 Quote
Baba Yaga Posted May 12, 2023 Report Posted May 12, 2023 Daisho? If the swords mei matches, or, and the Koshirae mei matches, papered, you "may" have a Daisho, In the true sense, a Daisho is pretty rare and looked at very favorably. The word Daisho in "Dealer Speek" is thrown around most frequently. 3 Quote
Ooitame Posted May 12, 2023 Author Report Posted May 12, 2023 On 5/12/2023 at 1:00 AM, PNSSHOGUN said: Hi Eric, congratulations. Do you have pictures of the Koshirae, the Katana and Wakizashi look to be from different time periods is all. Expand Hi @PNSSHOGUN thank you. 470 year difference. I sure can, Kosirare was an expnsive build, but we'll worth it; pics coming soon. @Baba Yaga I thought a Daisho is simply long, short sword. Quote
Ooitame Posted May 13, 2023 Author Report Posted May 13, 2023 For those of that wish to learn, including myself, what brought you too the inference of different ages... besides thickness , and mei @PNSSHOGUN. Also to be honest I am going to nakgo to kissaki close up for Hada, Gamon, Sughata. Then merger together. Time to google lol. Quote
Brian Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 https://www.geishasblade.com/what-is-a-daisho/ 2 2 Quote
vajo Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 On 5/12/2023 at 11:19 PM, Ooitame said: @Baba Yaga I thought a Daisho is simply long, short sword. Expand You mean a Daito. Quote
vajo Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 wehre is the daisho in the pictures? I see only two different swords. A Katana blade and a wakizashi blade. And both are from different schools Quote
ROKUJURO Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 Well, just a misunderstanding of terms, but hopefully Eric is happy! 3 Quote
Baba Yaga Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 On 5/13/2023 at 6:02 AM, Brian said: https://www.geishasblade.com/what-is-a-daisho/ Expand WE disused this when Darcey was just a Newbie, where do you think he got it from! Yes, a Daisho is in a sense a long and short sword. However, we as collectors describe a "True Daisho" and it's meaning. The information "at the time" was sampled from "papers". I understand "Papers" have become much more relaxed over the last few decades. Quote
Baba Yaga Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 On 5/13/2023 at 7:18 AM, vajo said: You mean a Daito. Expand Just a thought, not a conclusion. I would assume a Samurai would have Swords Long - Short / Koshirae from the same smith. Again, I was involved at the time with the top Dealers / Collectors in surmising this conclusion. Can we be wrong, hell yes. Quote
Matsunoki Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 I think the term Daisho means different things to different people, at different times and in different circumstances…..and it depends on whether you are talking about just the blades, just the koshirae or the whole package. Imo a “true blade daisho” is a pair of blades long/short made by the same smith at the same time as a pair. Very very rare. Probably expensive when new and even moreso now. Imo A daisho koshirae is simply completely matching katana/wakizashi or a Tachi/Tanto koshirae ….saya, tsuka, tsuba, and other hardware. Most of these (not that common nowadays) usually contain non matching blades often by different smiths and from different periods. These are what is “generally” meant by a daisho and are what we usually encounter….if we are lucky! still very desirable and expensive. The ultimate Daisho would be matching blades, same time same smith mounted in totally matching koshirae The wealth (and status) of the samurai would determine what he could afford. Most of them probably simply carried any old long sword together with any old short sword. If the mounts looked similar that would be good enough. The wealthier he was the higher up the daisho ladder he could climb. Has anyone on here got a true blade/koshirae daisho ie the full package that is from the Samurai era and not later assembled? ……lucky person! just some ramblings….fire away🙂 6 Quote
Ooitame Posted May 13, 2023 Author Report Posted May 13, 2023 Thanks for the link with Darcy's thoughts. As stated there are several definitions, for me this is a Daisho as the uchigatana had to have been worn by a samurai during its long life; made in 1478. The Katana while not worn by samurai of old, it was made during war time for battle use; estimation on date made 1943. Both blades were made during times of war and worn for such. The koshirae are similar, I did not want to build one for the showa blade, already has a good koshirae. Quote
Alex A Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 For me, its two swords used by a Samurai, with the same koshirae. Check out swords of the 47 Ronin for mismatches. Also, if someone puts two swords together and matches the koshirae, its a Daisho. Their Daisho. 4 1 Quote
Ooitame Posted May 13, 2023 Author Report Posted May 13, 2023 For the Kosihrae, the color was hard to send via photo to Japan, on the Katana. Texture is the same on both. I have a few more just need to work on the size. P.S. The gold Habaki was made special to fit the Kosihrae, as the mekugi on the uchigatana is high and I have a thick Tsuba. Quote
Alex A Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 Eric, il be honest. Think you may be pushing the boundaries of the term "daisho" Though look to be nice blades, That a Mino sword, who made it ? 1 Quote
Ooitame Posted May 13, 2023 Author Report Posted May 13, 2023 Thank you for your honest thoughts @Alex A. If I had a Koshirae made for the Katana, would it be then a Daisho, or just my Daisho? Thank you, nice swords indeed, If you come to the Orlando, show I would glady give you and others a private viewing. Should I use Daito instead? Quote
Alex A Posted May 13, 2023 Report Posted May 13, 2023 Strictly speaking, if you had koshirae made for both swords, then still your Daisho. But who cares, its yours. Quote
Ooitame Posted May 13, 2023 Author Report Posted May 13, 2023 On 5/13/2023 at 11:00 PM, Alex A said: But who cares, its yours. Expand Thank you for you thoughts. I agree, I think it that would be the choice for each person to make, old and new. 1 Quote
Stephen Posted May 14, 2023 Report Posted May 14, 2023 Not a true daisho shinto sho 1940s daito. To great expense matching koshirae .... After sometime matching tsuba. It is my daisho 8 5 Quote
Baba Yaga Posted May 14, 2023 Report Posted May 14, 2023 On 5/13/2023 at 5:06 PM, Matsunoki said: I think the term Daisho means different things to different people, at different times and in different circumstances…..and it depends on whether you are talking about just the blades, just the koshirae or the whole package. Imo a “true blade daisho” is a pair of blades long/short made by the same smith at the same time as a pair. Very very rare. Probably expensive when new and even moreso now. Imo A daisho koshirae is simply completely matching katana/wakizashi or a Tachi/Tanto koshirae ….saya, tsuka, tsuba, and other hardware. Most of these (not that common nowadays) usually contain non matching blades often by different smiths and from different periods. These are what is “generally” meant by a daisho and are what we usually encounter….if we are lucky! still very desirable and expensive. The ultimate Daisho would be matching blades, same time same smith mounted in totally matching koshirae The wealth (and status) of the samurai would determine what he could afford. Most of them probably simply carried any old long sword together with any old short sword. If the mounts looked similar that would be good enough. The wealthier he was the higher up the daisho ladder he could climb. Has anyone on here got a true blade/koshirae daisho ie the full package that is from the Samurai era and not later assembled? ……lucky person! just some ramblings….fire away🙂 Expand When collecting, I've always been a purist. It's the bane of my existence. How insane is it to display pieces in wood cases which are worth the price of luxury cars? My answer has always been, I don't have to build large garages. 2 1 Quote
Ooitame Posted May 14, 2023 Author Report Posted May 14, 2023 Nice set @Stephen! @Alex A apologizes forgot to answer your question, Bizen Norimitsu, and RJT Nagamitsu. 2 Quote
Matsunoki Posted May 14, 2023 Report Posted May 14, 2023 On 5/14/2023 at 2:25 PM, Baba Yaga said: I don't have to build large garages. Expand Neither do I. I just leave them standing on the drive🙂🙂 Quote
Alex A Posted May 14, 2023 Report Posted May 14, 2023 Was just looking over old photos of Samurai on Youtube, there's a few on there where fittings don't match. Think maybe some were not so pedantic as we are 5 Quote
Baba Yaga Posted May 14, 2023 Report Posted May 14, 2023 On 5/14/2023 at 4:23 PM, Alex A said: Was just looking over old photos of Samurai on Youtube, there's a few on there where fittings don't match. Think maybe some were not so pedantic as we are Expand Functionality over aesthetics, battle pick-up, Artistic rendering? Some show daisho, some don't. Seems to be psychological preference 1 Quote
Guest Simon R Posted May 18, 2023 Report Posted May 18, 2023 (edited) On 5/14/2023 at 6:37 PM, Alex A said: Many carrying a Tanto/Katana combo. Expand As did Sakamoto Ryōma and several other samurai of the Bakumatsu Jidai. Also shown is my daisho - a pretty closely matched katana and tanto. Edited May 18, 2023 by SRDRowson Bloody spellcheck!🤬 Quote
Baba Yaga Posted May 18, 2023 Report Posted May 18, 2023 No disrespect, but what does close mean? Does the papers say daito, or matched set? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.