Lewis B Posted September 22 Report Posted September 22 @PromoSorry for the hijack. I just read the whole thread and what an amazing journey. I wish I was able to attend the next NBTHK EB meeting in Manching to see it in person. It's become quite a celebrity piece on NMB it seems. It's unfortunate it didn't pass Juyo last Shinsa but I think 2023 was an odd one by all accounts. I'm glad Markus was able to shed so knowledgeable light on the blade and Sayagaki. My Shikkake also has Yuhin nari kanji (優品) and a suggestion by Tanobe sensei that it was a Juyo candidate. Might be worth resubmitting a few years down the road if you feel so inclined. Otherwise I'm sure you're basking in the pleasure of a special blade, with a wonderful and unique story, back in your possession. This ranks up there with Andrew's National Treasure Norishige Ebay find. Quote
cisco-san Posted September 26 Report Posted September 26 On 9/21/2024 at 6:15 PM, Promo said: Bringing it up a last time - hope to see all NBTHK Europe members from this forum in Manching (in Germany) in exactly one week, next Saturday. I'll bring this Masayuki along so that all of you can inspect it in person. Highly looking forward to it! unfortunately I am not able to join the meeting, even I would like to see this great blade in hands... Quote
Promo Posted September 30 Author Report Posted September 30 Re Saturday: great to have had the chance to also see faces behind nicknames, despite I sometimes felt misplaced among so many knowledgeable people. 1 Quote
sabiji Posted September 30 Report Posted September 30 36 minutes ago, Promo said: Re Saturday: great to have had the chance to also see faces behind nicknames, despite I sometimes felt misplaced among so many knowledgeable people. Georg, we had to thank you! Your Masayuki/Kiyomaro is an impressive sword with an excellent polish! In addition to the master, we were able to study two of his students: 2x Saito Kiyondo and 1x Minamoto (Suzuki) Masao. There is also a sword from the Hamabe school, the school where Kiyomaro was trained at the beginning of his career. Enclosed a bad photo of the table only (so as not to show any people...). 5 Quote
DKR Posted September 30 Report Posted September 30 5 hours ago, Promo said: Re Saturday: great to have had the chance to also see faces behind nicknames, despite I sometimes felt misplaced among so many knowledgeable people. I can only repeat and emphasize what Thomas has already written. An impressive blade with a very good polish. Absolutely excellent. And you were not out of place. This feeling is absolutely normal and not a mistake. I assure you that there were some who knew even less about Kiyomaro or quality criteria than you. When it comes to this, you can't learn something like that from books or even from the Internet. You only learn and understand something like that in practice with the blade in your hand. Of course it is very helpful if there is someone there who can explain something to you. And that is exactly what events like this are good for! You did everything right. You didn't fall into any traps. That alone is an achievement that most people wouldn't be able to achieve straight away. So from me again: Thank you very much for your willingness to make the blade accessible to an interested group of people. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.