Fraud Help

PhoenixDude · February 7, 2018

All, I recently sold a sword to a potential buyer who is now filing a claim with paypal stating the sword does not match the description of the item, and that I misrepresented it. Im concerned he may be trying to defraud me of the payment for the item by sending me a different sword back in the returns process. Any advice?

TETSUGENDO · February 7, 2018

Jay,

Avoid Paypal whenever possible!

-StevenK

John A Stuart · February 7, 2018

Pics, pics and more pics. The best proof I can think of. Good luck. John

PNSSHOGUN · February 7, 2018

Pics, pics and more pics. The best proof I can think of. Good luck. John

Pictures, screenshots of original listings, email logs and professional appraisals will be your best bet.

Or send his address to Stephen....

Alex A · February 7, 2018

Whats he saying exactly with regards not matching the description?

vajo · February 7, 2018

Backsending another sword would be criminal. Did you have enough good pictures from the nakago and the blade?

Did you have any return accepted?

Ken-Hawaii · February 7, 2018

Jay, assuming you mailed it, contact the local Postmaster about filing a fraud charge against the buyer. Might not get very far, but it should give him second thoughts.

ROKUJURO · February 7, 2018

.....I'm concerned he may be trying to defraud me of the payment for the item by sending me a different sword back in the returns process. Any advice?

Jay,

Yes. Unless he really did so, you can't do much.

christianmalterre · February 7, 2018

did you offer this sword via the NMB here ?

if yes- no way the buyer could complain, despite he will loose face if not comporting correctly!

( maybe fruitful to publish this gentlemens name here ? )

Christian

TheGermanBastard · February 7, 2018

It is now up to PayPal. One has to argue with them now. Good luck.

Then you have to wait and see what happens. Getting a different sword returned would be my least concern. If he wants to defraud you then he will not send you back anything but a nice brick at best

Who knows, maybe he is just a picky buyer. You will then end up loosing a one way postage. That is still annoying but not a big deakl.

You will just have to wait and see what happens. As others said, best don't do PayPal if you want to avoid this kind of thing. But if you do then you have to live with their random decisions.

TheGermanBastard · February 7, 2018

And to make this clear: So far this thing is a pain in the ass from your point of view but no fraud (yet).

Stephen · February 7, 2018

Where's Jay?

Call paypal tell them whats going on. The sooner the better.

TheGermanBastard · February 7, 2018

what's going on is that someone has initiated a retutn through paypal for whatever reasons and they will say in 99% of the cases that he is to return the item and get back his money. this has happened to any seller using paypal on more than one occasion before and will continue. anything else is just speculation driven by fear until the sword does not arrive in oroginal condition

Brian · February 7, 2018

Paypal will side with the buyer every time.
No way to win with them. Just hope the buyer sends the sword back, sometimes PP lets them keep it.

Stephen · February 7, 2018

Not 100% true, when i sold the low end wak to UK and they cited like charges , PP took my side. Even tho you know their evil, treat each case as they will help.

vajo · February 7, 2018

Its unfair to look only on the sellers side. A buyer has the risk to recieve garbage or see his money in neverland.

The best is to speak with the seller.

Wayben · February 7, 2018

Pics, pics and more pics. The best proof I can think of. Good luck. John

Unfortunately, pics don't prove that you sent that sword. A buyer can argue that the sword he sent back is the one you delivered. Any transaction involves a lot of trust on both sides, leaving both sides open to scams.

Surfson · February 8, 2018

Let us know if your fears come true. Until then, hope for the best.

Dave R · February 8, 2018

Have you asked him for photo's of what he says arrived?

Stephen · February 8, 2018

Comments are moot unless Jay comes back in to let us know more. He probably left it after the first comment which was like "close that door, the dog just ran away"!

NihontoEurope · February 8, 2018

Pics, pics and more pics. The best proof I can think of. Good luck. John

This is why I make videos of the swords. If there is any doubt for any reason. the video shows everything. Every little scratch.

I think you should do this first.

Check your pictures. Are they really accurate?

90% of the pics here (and elsewhere) really bad. Maybe the customer/buyer thinks you tricked him by bad photos?

If there is no doubt about the pictures and description of the goods, go ahead to the next step.

That is my recommendation.

TheGermanBastard · February 8, 2018

@ Stephen: The dog has not even left teh building yet As long as there has no fraud happened yet I think it is just fear. There is also way too little information on the table. Who knows, maybe the buyer is just picky, maybe he is a fraud or bulletsprinkler just missed a Kizu by accident. A while ago I sold a blade which I have had for almost a decade to a board member. I was very fond of the blade and sent it as I usually do upfront, only asking payment after the receival. Guess what: The blade had a bend! I missed that despite having had the blade for such a long time. I was very embarrassed and felt ashamed. So either I would have taken the sword back for a full refund or offered a partial refund. The buyer liked the blade very much so I offered a partial refund and he has been very happy with his purchase. Did I misrepesent the swod? Yes I did! Due to mere stupidness and ignorance of my very own. So I stood up for my fault and everybody was happy afterwards. Mistakes happen.

Then one also has to keep in mind that people have become used to the attitude of ordering things and returning them for no reason. Ask any online shop owner. People order something, gets what they purchased but return it for no reason. Maybe it is that kind of buyer. We don't know.

All we know for nos is that there has (yet) been no fraud.

Stephen · February 8, 2018

LUIS

i was referring to the first response, dont use ebay, bit late for that advise dont you think?

Jay has not come back so i dont see what everyone is going on about!

TheGermanBastard · February 8, 2018

Hello Stephen, I had misunderstood your posting. Sorry!

Well said regarding the topic.

PhoenixDude · February 8, 2018

Update,he sent pics of the sword i sent. He says hes sending it back, will see what i get in the mail.

Stephen · February 8, 2018

buyers remorse, if he altered it in anyway PP will side with you and he has to pay, been there done that.

TheGermanBastard · February 8, 2018

buyers remorse, if he altered it in anyway PP will side with you and he has to pay, been there done that.

So in this game one must also hope that the seller is honest, too and does not make false claims either.

TETSUGENDO · February 8, 2018

So,summing it up..........

Avoid Paypal whenever possible.

Be careful on Ebay.

Don't jump to unfounded conclusions.

Relax, life is too short , save the panic for real calamity....there will be plenty of it!

-StevenK

Dave R · February 8, 2018

Nowt much wrong with Ebay or Paypal, every market, every payment option has it's problems.

Brian · February 9, 2018

Plenty wrong with both eBay and Paypal.
You are in the UK Dave, eBay doesn't even deem you worthy of viewing half the stuff for sale. You get their cute little edited version of eBay. eBay Lite. No sharp or pointy stuff for you....you can't be trusted.
As for Paypal, they should stick to being a money substitute and stop trying to decide what we can use it for. If I want to buy something legal, why should I have to run it through their list of morally acceptable stuff that they think I may own. They get their damn fees, so shut up and take my money.
/rant.

Sign In

Fraud Help

Recommended Posts

Join the conversation