cisco-san Posted September 24, 2013 Report Posted September 24, 2013 Hello, this blade has been offered to me. It is signed Oite Minamoto Masakatsu Motome and Ishido Unju Korekazu tsukuru and is dated July 1863 (see picture below). The blade is mounted into a Shin Gunto Koshirae. As this is a quite famous smith and the price seems o.k. (maybe to cheap :-) )I would kindly ask for your thoughts on this Mei.... Of course I tried it to compare it with some references, but came to no real conclusion (probably it is gimei !!) Many thanks in advance Klaus Quote
Brian Posted September 24, 2013 Report Posted September 24, 2013 I would not trust a website that doesn't give info about themselves, their location or the people who work there. From the whois, they appear to be in Canada, but Their "About Us" page is ridiculously lacking. That doesn't instill confidence in their products. Their page is in Chinese and English too...odd. Products look ok...but you have to know who you are buying from. Brian Quote
Stephen Posted September 24, 2013 Report Posted September 24, 2013 link please, i cant read the web page Quote
Brian Posted September 24, 2013 Report Posted September 24, 2013 pm sent, just in case he wants to keep the site to himself :lol: Brian Quote
takakage Posted September 24, 2013 Report Posted September 24, 2013 Hi, Some kanji and tagane are very différent to the soshin mei of him....... Quote
cisco-san Posted September 26, 2013 Author Report Posted September 26, 2013 Hi, Some kanji and tagane are very différent to the soshin mei of him....... This is the same what I found out which my limited resources, but as I am still a newbie and nobody knows :D Thanks Klaus Quote
Surfson Posted September 26, 2013 Report Posted September 26, 2013 i believe that I bought a sword from this guy a couple of years ago. If it is the one I am thinking of, he is more an expert in Chinese art, but carries some Japanese swords. He is in Canada, and I had no problem with the transaction. I have no opinion about the Korekazu. Cheers, Bob Quote
tanto Posted September 27, 2013 Report Posted September 27, 2013 I would not trust a website that doesn't give info about themselves, their location or the people who work there.From the whois, they appear to be in Canada, but Their "About Us" page is ridiculously lacking. That doesn't instill confidence in their products. Their page is in Chinese and English too...odd. Products look ok...but you have to know who you are buying from. Brian Hi Brian, Thank you for your great suggestion. The mentioned website is new and belongs to me. I will listen to all suggestions and improve it. Something about myself, I am an economist, graduated from McGill University Master of Arts in 1988. I have been collecting antique and nihonto for over 20 years in Toronto Canada. Over these years, I have been trading swords to some members/users from this board through diffenert channels. If anyone has any questions or comments, please let me know. Thank you everybody. Quote
Alan Morton Posted September 27, 2013 Report Posted September 27, 2013 HI Klaus, I think if you look in Shin Shinto Nihon to Koza page 408 Kajhei Gimei of Kiyomaro you will find the real maker of your Korekazu, Kajhei (Hosada Naomitsu), his way of chiseling mei is a dead ringer for the one on your sword. I just recently deliberately bought a gimei Kotetsu that I thought was an excellent sword even though a fake by Kajihei and have sent it off for repolish in Japan regards Alan Quote
cisco-san Posted September 27, 2013 Author Report Posted September 27, 2013 HI Klaus, I think if you look in Shin Shinto Nihon to Koza page 408 Kajhei Gimei of Kiyomaro you will find the real maker of your Korekazu, Kajhei (Hosada Naomitsu), his way of chiseling mei is a dead ringer for the one on your sword. I just recently deliberately bought a gimei Kotetsu that I thought was an excellent sword even though a fake by Kajihei and have sent it off for repolish in Japan regards Alan Hi Alan, many thanks for great information - I will do so!! kind Regards from Vienna Klaus Quote
Brian Posted September 27, 2013 Report Posted September 27, 2013 Tenny, Good to hear from the owner. As I mentioned..when I look at a new website, I want to see a paragraph saying : "Hi, My name is xxx and I am a dealer in XXXX. My background is..... and my contact details are xxxx" Once I see that, I feel a lot better about buying from that dealer, and easier to ask who has dealt with them before. Glad to hear from others who dealt with you..so all seems good here, and I will make sure I add the site to the links page if it isn't there. Feel free to post from time to time and inform us of new products, specials etc. Dealers can definitely benefit from a NMB presence. Brian Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.