I really appreciate your bluntness and willingness to help! You have the perspective of someone steeped in knowledge and appreciation for some of the most beautiful works of art to come out of Japan - genuine Nihontō with unique and well cared qualities. I really respect that seasoned viewpoint, and I respect that you are concerned with making sure I completely understand that quality bar moving forward.
At the end of the day, this junker of a blade has taught me so much, through my research and the willingness of people like you to help me; about what to look for, how to differentiate time periods, how aspects of tempering and styles/signatures of the Nakago help provide historical context, and the parts of the Nihontō to most appreciate from an artistic and aesthetic perspective. I am honored and humbled by this experience, and I’ll always have that thanks to this item of someone’s shared history.
Perhaps you are right, perhaps I will tire of this blade. Perhaps it was genuinely designed for nothing more than deception and foolishness. But I hope, ultimately, that it serves as a wonderful reminder of the way that a community of likeminded, well meaning collectors and historians came together to help me, for no other reason than a shared experience and love of the Japanese sword.
I have this junker to thank, and I think I’ll always respect it for that.
-Vincent