Jump to content

Scogg

Gold Tier
  • Posts

    1,137
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    7

Everything posted by Scogg

  1. I noticed that too The original poster deleted the content of his post with the edit tool; and replaced the title with a “.” I think the mods deleted it for good after that. You’re not that daft yet! cheers, -Sam
  2. Hi Vincent, To my novice eye, it looks authentic, and probably antique (although impossible for me to tell how old) Looks like a very crude and low quality shortening of a longer blade - probably to appeal to the tourist market. The nakago looks bad, and the spine/mune look pretty funky. Personally, I would avoid it unless it were being given away... And i've been known to buy swords in less than ideal condition/quality. Just my two cents, Best of luck, -Sam Edit: Brian beat me to it! And he's more knowledgeable than me Cheers!
  3. @Alex A Interesting! Thank you for that! I'll have to investigate my sword a bit more, and maybe compare it to my Yamato koto blade in the sun - to maybe get a better idea of the steel color. Now i'm beginning to wonder if that blue hue is a reflection of the blue sky... Anyway, thank you again! Ya'll have given me a lot to look into! Just comparing the sword between Sue-Bizen and Mino has been informative and helpful Next I'll investigate the koshirae a bit. I'd like to freshen up my knowledge on WW2 sword fittings! Cheers, ya'll have been a big help as always -Sam
  4. That’s true! I guess it technically is a wakizashi. It “feels” very much like a katana with all the type 98 mounts, but the blade measures just under 24 inches Do you think it’s ubu? I thought suriage because the hamon runs into the nakago patina. I know that’s not always the best identifier though Thanks for pointing that out! cheers, -Sam
  5. Thank you both! I also suspect it to be older than Shinto - just because the patina and shape feel much different than my Shinto mino katana. But that’s just my very novice observation That last photos are 100% natural sunlight, so that blue hue is hopefully a representation of steel color. That’s so hard to capture, but it does appear to have a blueish look to it Thank you! -Sam
  6. Got some good sunlight photos during this rare sunny October day Cheers, -Sam
  7. A best guess is a great start and all that I ask! I appreciate the input Right or wrong, every guess gets my nose into my books, and comparing features to the blade Starting with input and opinions from y’all helps me narrow my search and encourages my interest. It all helps me learn! Thanks again, -Sam
  8. Thank you for your input! On this post, and my others. I’ve learned a lot following the leads you’ve given me The heavy hadori is unfortunate, and makes some detail hard to see And thank you @Alex A! Bizen was my first thought and I’m still leaning that way a bit thanks to you both! cheers, -Sam
  9. I recently acquired this blade in Type 98 Gunto koshirae. Seems to be out of polish but in decent condition, the tsuka has some damage. The previous menuki had been nearly pulverized, so I replaced it with a section of chopstick for the short-term. I also added the tassel. Otherwise this is as-found Shinogi Zukuri Mumei Hamon: Notare Sori: Torisori Mune: Iorimune file marks: Kiri? nakagojiri: kurijiri boshi: notare komi? Nagasa: 60.3cm (23.74 in) total length: 75.5cm (29.7 in) sori: 2cm (0.787 in) Motohaba: 28.5mm Sakihaba: 20mm motokasane: 6.3mm sakikasane: 4.7mm Kissaki: 31.9mm I’ve got a low budget, and a thing for mumei over gimei. I enjoy the more dramatic Sori than my other swords. I also love the ww2 koshirae, and have always wanted a sword in gunto fittings. I believe the blade to be suriage and probably koto. trying to get good shots of the hada but it’s hard to see and my photography skills and equipment are still greatly lacking. Sharing for opinions, and discussion - to learn what I can from my new sword. I would love a closer estimate on its possible age Also, the sarute is a fairly simple metal band. Could I hypothetically purchase a more decorative gunto sarute and replace it? Or is that probably not worth it? more photos in additional comments* Thanks for reading, Cheers, -Sam
  10. Visiting the southern Oregon coast on my honeymoon, and stopped in Brookings to view this sword. Really interesting bit of World War Two history, that I’ve always wanted to see in-person. It’s in a big plastic case in a library, so it was challenging to get a good photo. I wish I could see the nakago Heres a link with some of the history: https://www.brooking....us/291/Fujita-Sword Hope you enjoy! Cheers, -Sam
  11. Looks like a great buy Jon! Its so tough to capture the jihada in images. Are you able to see it in-hand? Thanks for sharing pieces of your collection, Cheers, -Sam
  12. I'm not familiar with Mr. Boomershine, But what did he tell you about the blade? Someone who is polishing Nihonto, and also had it in-hand, should be able to tell you more than we can with just these images
  13. One thing that I notice is the lack of the “swallowtail” shape on the rear wings of the koshirae parts. Might just be the butterfly’s positioning Very nice looking koshirae, and fun sounding project. I’m jealous, and wish you luck!
  14. It looks extremely similar. I'd say definitely/probably swallowtail butterfly (ageha) It has very slight differences to the Taira clan Ageha mon. Most noticeably the antenna on the Taira Clan Mon makes a full swirl/loop above the wing Whereas your ageha antenna appears to loop behind the wing Lovely piece. I'd love to see more/closer photos
  15. I'm just a low-level militaria collector, and nihonto novice - so please take my following statement with a grain of salt: I think you got a great deal with that sword for $1000; it looks really nice. Personally, if I were considering spending ~$2500 on a gunto, I would not spend it on the sword in question; from the eBay link. Best of luck, Cheers, -Sam Edit: I hope i'm not breaking any rules here - opinionating on the price of a sale... If so, my apologies, and please delete
  16. Hada shows mostly masame throughout, with a couple spots of mokume. I was told Yamato Tegai by the togishi - but it has not been to shinsa Love this topic, information, and photos. The small spots of mokume on my sword are enjoyable to admire.
  17. I believe the Showa stamp indicates that the sword is not traditionally made in some way
  18. Good questions that I’ve wondered also I’ve assumed it’s a combination of things. Maybe the overall length, and an aesthetic choice. Looking forward to what others have to say Here are my two Wakizashi with pretty different profiles; and tsuka to nakago lengths Cheers, -Sam
  19. I would request more photos, especially of the nakago Hard to see, but that kind of looks like an arsenal stamp. Which would suggest it’s Showato rather than Gendaito. Looks like maybe a gifu stamp, or anchor? The bold hada would give me pause also… not sure what to make of that If I were considering this purchase, I’d ask for a lot more photos best of luck, edited for clarity, -Sam
  20. Scogg

    Shikomizue

    Very cool! I would love to see more photos of the hand guard mechanism Cheers, -Sam
  21. Unfortunately, I’ve seen many nearly identical fakes That rough and bold Damascus pattern is one of many giveaways Here’s a link with some helpful info http://www.jssus.org...japanese_swords.html Cheers, and best of luck
  22. Objectively? Probably not. Subjectively? Totally!
×
×
  • Create New...