GeorgeLuucas

I'd like to see the saya on that Naginata "gunto"... I am inclined to agree with Stephen. Cool piece nonetheless! Cheers, -Sam Edit: I see now in the original post, that it came with NO saya. Strengthening Stephens theory, IMO.

I cannot speak to the generation unfortunately. I must say, I really like that horimono… It’s gorgeous! Thank you for sharing! It looks like a really beautiful sword. Cheers, -Sam

These have all the hallmarks of modern made reproductions or fakes. These are the kinds of swords you can find at the shopping mall or on Amazon best of luck, -Sam

I know you already said you don’t like the gunto aesthetic. Which is totally understandable! BUT Just to throw this out there: There’s a lot of different gunto koshirae. Some are more handsome than others in my opinion; and they vary in quality to a degree. Sorry if this is presumptuous and something you’re already well aware of. The only reason I bring it up, is because IF there is a koshirae that you like, it would be more affordable to find a Gendaito with exsisting koshirae than making a new set. With some ww2 history to boot! Welcome to the forum! best of luck, -Sam (images taken from google)

The flower on the tsuka (handle), is cherry blossom *edit: I’m wrong, it’s a plum blossom. Thanks @Kiipu My apologies OP

Jasmine is my best guess... What makes identification challenging are the grassy parts behind the flower. Without those, I'd say definitely jasmine. Phlox was my first thought, then I considered some kind of lily. Best of luck, Cheers, -Sam

It is much like the hook design on my Type 98’s hanger chain Cheers, -Sam

Here's a helpful link on the different terminology surrounding mei. Typically a smith signs their name on the side of the sword that faces outward when worn - so depending on the type of sword (tachi vs katana), you might see signatures on different sides of the nakago http://www.ncjsc.org/gloss_mei-1.html *And there are always exceptions to the rule, especially when gimei is on the table. Best of luck, -Sam

The seppa look like they have their edges “cut off” so they don’t obscure the kozuka hitsu-ana, Or maybe another part of the tsuba. I have a sword with seppa like that Looks like there’s also a leather seppa, which was probably added recently to prevent rattling

Definitely a large kissaki! I’m not quite knowledgeable enough to tell if it might be a Nagamaki. A look at the whole sugata, without habiki, would help those who are. My guess would be that it’s just a strong o-kissaki on a katana or wakizashi Best of luck, -Sam

It looks like o-kissaki to me Hard to tell from your photo, does it turn back at all? Image from google for reference:

I think that's a big part of the issue here... What are we discussing? Gassan Minamoto Sadakazu? Nihonto? Japanese military swords? Arsenal Blades? Auctions? Dealers? Books? I'd still like to know what you're trying to collect, and why? (see my comment on page 2). Are you looking for ww2 swords, nihonto, both? Are you collecting for your own personal gratification, or are you treasure hunting and trying to buy and resell? I don't meant to sound rude, but answers to these questions might quell many of the judgements from the so called "babbling critics". Right now it just seems like you want some type of valuable Japanese sword for reasons unknown. Last attempt before I'm out , Sincerely, -Sam

@Swords it might be helpful to explain to us your collecting goals. Right now it just seems like you’re throwing everything at the wall to see what sticks Do you simply want an authentic Japanese sword as a conversation piece for your larger militaria collection? Is your goal to appreciate the art in Nihonto, and learn everything you can? Or are you treasure hunting trying to buy and resell? Other motivation/goal perhaps? All the best, Happy new year, -Sam

Wow, gorgeous blade and stunning koshirae. If anyone was thinking of a belated Christmas gift for me…

What raised my eyebrows on this particular sword was this feature in the shinogiji, that looks almost Unokubi Zukuri maybe? I usually see similar features on naginata or further up the blade Now I’m wondering if it’s a glare of the light

Yeah it looks in very bad condition. Or maybe someone foolishly buffed it out at some point. Or maybe a combination of some of the above The combination of poor photo quality, and lack of any pictures focusing on the kissaki, makes me wonder how deep that corrosion is

Shipping from Japan with no papers… Poor condition. But I thought I’d share because of the interesting shape. Hamichi and munemichi look like it’s got some life Don’t worry, I won’t be buying. But I would love to hear thoughts! https://www.ebay.com/itm/134866841748?hash=item1f66b0b094

The mihaba on that last one is wiiiiide Is that one of those swords designed specifically for tameshigiri?

For what it's worth, according to the listing itself, it's stated that the sword is "signed made by Gassan Minamoto Sadakazu" It does NOT state that it was made by Gassan Minamoto Sadakazu, and offers no guarantee on mei legitimacy. It simply states the translation on the nakago, and offers some info about the smith it claims to be. I know that's a little tricky with the semantics, but it's something to look out for on unpapared blades. For example: I find a painting and write "Picasso" on it, then list the item as "painting signed Picasso" - which is technically true... but it's still not actually painted or signed by Picasso

Still very tempted. It has been a while since I've taken a trip to Vegas. My attendance aside, I hope ya'll have a great time and see some awesome items! Please share photos once ya'll are home and settled Cheers, -Sam

Being from Somerset, I imagine your climate is similar to mine (similar latitude); which also appears to be close-ish to the ocean / salt water Over here we've got grey skies, dank earth, and frequent mold issues - and oiling nihonto is a MUST I use this stuff (WITHOUT THE STONE!) https://www.amazon.c...284507_t1_B00TCZEV36

I would think if one jihada were superior to others, then it would have been slowly adopted by most smiths. I personally view it as an artistic or traditional feature before a practical one I really like mokume hada Best of luck, -Sam

Thanks Jussi, this is really interesting Fist thing that stands out, is only ONE wakizashi! Great data, and thanks for the translation, Cheers, -Sam

This whole thread is a fantastic example of the can-of-worms I try to avoid by only collecting: unpapered mumei and/or papered zaimei For me it comes down to personal preference as the collector. I often attend militaria shows, and frequently witness people buying gimei swords over mumei swords simply because "it's signed" - with no further thought or care. Personally, I'd rather have a sword with a big flaw than a fake signature. I consider gimei not only dishonest, but the opposite of a conversation piece... By the time I explain all the ins-and-outs of the history of gimei, the person i'm conversing with will have lost all interest. I like the advice of buying the blade, and not the signature; but to get to that point I need a higher level of knowledge and need to see more shoshin swords. Just my two cents -Sam

I also struggle with image sizing sometimes. My phone likes to take HUGE images apparently. I often get around this issue, by taking a screenshot of the image I have just taken - then cropping the image to highlight the item - and deleting the original so I don't have multiple photos of the same thing. The screenshot and cropped version of your picture should be considerably smaller in file size than the original. Be careful to crop the image appropriately, so you don't include your phones battery life, time, and reception %. Best of luck, and cool sword, -Sam