Alex A

Does anyone know if Lulu does one of those Christmas discounts every year?. A third off when you spend a certain amount. Thats the time to buy.

Agreed, good read, now im speculating. Early Edo period for instance, after Sekigahara, 500,000 unemployed samurai without income or support, two Ronin rebellions, stories infact of unemployed Samurai selling their swords. Now then, a knock on effect, certain smiths hitting difficult times. To make a living, these particular smiths may have had to sell a number of swords off at give away prices. If that where the case, would they have been likely to sign?, Would that explain a number of mumei Edo swords?, or have i drank too much coffee?

"And the other one my girlfriend convinced me to buy" Your a lucky man Andi

Hi Gary, Hira-zukuri first appeared on early tachi. After the Heian period (after 806), Tanto and Ko-wakizashi carried on in that style. (From Connoisseurs). Later Hira-zukuri wakizashi are simply throwback to the past.

Great link, new to me, thanks!

Looks great Paul, wish i was able to attend.

Hi Nick, my nihonto budget limits me to the title of "enthusiast", rather than that of "collector", so now i will only buy a sword if it jumps out and says "buy me". My favourite sword is my mumei/suriage Nobukuni wakizashi. The papers place it to late Nanbokucho period. If the NBTHK cant decide which smith made it, than i sure as hell cant either (Read similar quotes that amused me on the net). I think thats part of the reason i find it interesting, im looking into it at the moment. The sword, i just find interesting, its age, the horimono, and the fact the blade is packed with activities. The sword is a little worn maybe, but i think its great , il forgive due to old age.

Hi Ed, it did catch me out too, one day hopefully, i will come across something in this hobby thats straightforward. :?

Hi Ed, i had a quick look through Fujishiros this afternoon. The zen in the 3rd picture is from page 120, plate 3, Hizen Kuni Junin Fujiwara Tadayoshi.

Hi Isidro, agree with Ed. Infact, nothing seems to look right when compared to other examples in Fujishiros, have a look on the net for comparison.

Thanks for the heads up John, £7.12, now thats affordable... http://www.lulu.com/gb/en/shop/joseph-b ... 57328.html

Thank you Gabriel, you have been extremely helpful indeed

Cheers Gabriel, your write up as been very helpful, id been planning on learning something about Horimono. I have a wakizashi from the late Nanbokucho period, the horimono as diminished with polishing over the years and did have me curious. I had the horimono down as Suken previously, but i believe Hoken or Sankoken is the correct term.

"I have personally watched mumei katana which have nics and forging flaws sold for double their normal value just because they were sold through a well known dealer. When the buyer tries to resell the sword after a few people have pointed out the flaws they can't achieve half the original price" Bang on Trent, spend your money wisely Andres....

I hope im wrong, but the tsuba in question looks like it was made yesterday. It looks new, wheres the ware? and patina? (natural patina). The reverse of the seppa die especially, stands out to me as a modern attempt at an aged patina.

Hi Pete, looks like a modern chinese cast tsuba to me.

Very nice blade Jon, from a good year too

Il have me one of those, thankyou Markus.

Hi Ken, you bring up something i have thought about recently, sword size/cutting tests. Surely stouter heavier swords with wider sakihaba would have made better cutting swords. Mass x velocity= momentum. I think its fair to say that the rankings where not accurate. I suppose the attraction with these swords is the added historic value.

Interesting graph Gabriel, 1590 clunker, Dotanuki by any chance?

Thanks Guido.

I see, cheers Guido That makes me ask, if a sword with a cutting test inscription goes to get papered, is the inscription also evaluated?, aplogies ken for going off on tangent!

How do we know if a cutting test inscription is authentic?, not all come with silver or gold inlay. If it adds value then surely there must be fakes?

Must be nice to own such an amazing piece of history.

One could combat this situation by throwing in a curve ball order, Moroha-zukuri wak or something? :lol: