Ian B3HR2UH

Good that you asked before buying . It is a Chinese fake .

Jeff , it is hard to judge blades when you are holding them in your hands , even more difficult from photos and almost impossible from crummy photos like these . You can see almost no hada or hamon in the photos . I doubt that even Mr Tanobe himself could tell you much from these photos .

Thanks for your articles Alexander . The thought that items that I now own have passed through the hands of previous collectors ,who have also treasured them , has always interested me . One minor correction. In your article on Walter Behrens you perpetuate the myth that Henri Joly was Belgian . He was born on the 24th of Feb 1878 at Chartres France . His 1901 and 1911 census entries confim that he was French . The attached tsuba is one of two I have that were once part of Henri Joly's collection .

It IS the typical late shin gunto blade

It's not a Gendai sword , it is not made pre war , it is a classic oil tempered piece mass produced during the war years .

This shows that there are still good things out there to hunt for, not just the mediocre pieces that the board gets bombarded with . Congratulations Paul

I would have thought that you will get more for it in the west than trying to sell it to a dealer in Japan

It is a junker, give it a wide berth

This is not most likely fake but definitely 110 % fake , as is the kozuka

The mei ( signature ) is so freshly cut that it is obvious that this is a showa era blade , you are deluding yourself if you think otherwise

Your hamon is grey because the sword is not in original polish having been cleaned up by someone . The opinion you are quoting shows just how little it's author knows

The seller is right it is probably made in the 1940's . The second opinion giver knows nothing .

73 Yasuyo This sword is by Shumenokami Ichi no hira Yasuyo not Yasuyori . It was owned by the Miyasaka Shrine in Kagoshima Prefecture who handed it over to the Ibusuki police in December 1945. The blade is dated 1723 and is 33 .5 inches long . There are photographs of the sword and the lengthy inscription on the nakago in the documents from the American Archives that Stephen Thorpe shared with us . Attached to this is a copy of one of those pictures showing the Shirasaya, box and lacquered box that accompanied the sword . Further photos are on page 82 of Satsuma no katana no Tsuba by Fukunaga

Look at where the top ashi is in relation to the koiguchi . This is all wrong - avoid it .

70 Peony wakizashi 71 Nagamitsu Thanks for posting this Brett . The attached photo shows 70 and 71 which were taken from the Aso Shrine in 1945 and remain missing

I have seen a couple with brown lacquered same scabbards but never one with green binding .This combination would be extremely unusual I would be very very suspicious of this and if it is coming out of Japan I would assume it has been rewrapped

Christies sold one in 1994 with a copper blade signed Kano Natsuo , Funada Ikkin , Tsuchiya Yasuchika and Yokoya Tenmin !

Army Surgeon Lieutenant Kamisaka Yoshinosuke

I thought this one was interesting , a naval officer with a Shinto gunto

This one is signed Yanagawa Naomasa but the mei doesn't match those in Kinko Meikan or Wakayama. Bonham's did sell a very similar pair in 2023 which had Tokubetsu Kicho papers and a Sato Kanzan attribution to Naomasa

Similar ones to this piece in Japanese publications are labelled Satsuma or Oda school